Whatnot vs eBay Fees: Which One Costs You Less?
If you sell trading cards, coins, collectibles or clothes, you've probably wondered whether Whatnot or eBay keeps less of your money. The answer depends on the category, the price and, on Whatnot, how much you sell in a month. Here's the comparison in real dollars, using each platform's official fee pages.
Quick answer: Whatnot's fees are lower than eBay's for cards, coins, collectibles and most clothing. Whatnot charges 8% commission on the item price (4% for coins) plus 2.9% + $0.30 processing; eBay charges 13.25% on cards and 13.6% in most categories, on the item, shipping and tax, plus $0.40 per order. A $40 card with $5 shipping leaves $35.19 on Whatnot and $33.64 on eBay.
The short answer
Whatnot charges less than eBay for the things most people sell there. On a $40 trading card where the buyer pays $5 shipping, you keep $35.19 on Whatnot and $33.64 on eBay. The gap gets wider as the price goes up, and very wide above $1,500 because of a Whatnot promotion.
That doesn't make Whatnot the right choice for every item. Whatnot sales mostly happen in live shows, which take time to run, while an eBay listing sells on its own. Below we compare the fees, then the trade-offs.
How each app charges
Whatnot (US, Standard tier):
- commission on the item price only, not on shipping or tax: 8% in most categories and 4% for coins and money,
- payment processing of 2.9% + $0.30 on the whole order, including shipping and tax,
- 0% commission on the part of the item price above $1,500 in eligible categories (a limited-time promotion),
- no fee to list, and the shipping the buyer pays goes to Whatnot's prepaid label.
Your commission rate drops as your sales grow. Whatnot sets a tier from your total sales over a four-week period, and that tier's rates apply in the next period.
eBay (US, no Store subscription):
- a final value fee on the total sale (item, shipping and sales tax): 13.25% for trading cards, comics and coins (not bullion), 13.6% for most other categories, up to $7,500,
- a per-order fee of $0.30 on orders of $10 or less and $0.40 above that,
- $0.35 insertion fees, but only after 250 free listings a month.
So Whatnot's total on a normal sale is roughly 8% plus about 3%, and eBay's is roughly 13% plus the per-order fee, charged on a bigger base.
Trading cards: what you keep
Sports card singles, buyer pays $5 shipping, no sales tax, Whatnot Standard tier.
| Card price | Whatnot fees | Whatnot payout | eBay fees | eBay payout |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $10 | $1.54 | $8.46 | $2.39 | $7.61 |
| $40 | $4.81 | $35.19 | $6.36 | $33.64 |
| $100 | $11.35 | $88.65 | $14.31 | $85.69 |
| $500 | $54.95 | $445.05 | $67.31 | $432.69 |
| $2,000 | $178.45 | $1,821.55 | $266.06 | $1,733.94 |
On eBay we assume your label costs the same $5 the buyer pays, so shipping washes out on both apps and the payouts are directly comparable.
At $2,000 the difference is big because Whatnot charges no commission on the $500 above $1,500, while eBay's 13.25% applies to the whole sale. Whatnot calls that a limited-time promotion, so check the Whatnot fee guide before you count on it for a big card.
Coins and money
Whatnot's coins rate is half its normal rate. On eBay, coins (other than bullion) pay the same 13.25% as trading cards.
| $100 coin, $5 shipping | Whatnot | eBay |
|---|---|---|
| Fees | $7.35 | $14.31 |
| You keep | $92.65 | $85.69 |
Bullion is different on eBay: 13.6% up to $7,500 and 7% on the whole sale above that. For bullion, use the bullion category in the eBay fee calculator.
Clothes and other categories
Fashion pays Whatnot's normal 8% (no $1,500 promotion), and on eBay most clothing is in the 13.6% "most categories" group.
| Fashion item, $8 shipping | Whatnot fees | Whatnot payout | eBay fees | eBay payout |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $40 | $4.89 | $35.11 | $6.93 | $33.07 |
| $100 | $11.43 | $88.57 | $15.09 | $84.91 |
Two exceptions on eBay. Athletic shoes sold for $150 or more pay just 8% with no per-order fee, which beats Whatnot: on a $200 pair with $8 shipping, eBay's fees are $16.64 and Whatnot's are $22.33. Women's handbags go the other way: 15% on eBay up to $2,000. Pick the matching category in each calculator.
Sales tax: both apps take a cut, in different ways
Neither app lets you keep the sales tax, but both charge a fee on it. Whatnot's 2.9% processing includes tax; its commission doesn't. eBay's whole final value fee includes tax.
On a $100 card with $5 shipping and 8% sales tax, Whatnot's fees go from $11.35 to $11.59, while eBay's go from $14.31 to $15.43. Tax hurts more on eBay because its percentage is higher and applies to everything.
Whatnot tiers make the gap bigger
The numbers above use Whatnot's Standard tier, which covers sellers with under $15,000 in sales in a four-week period. Sell more and your rate falls in the next period. A $100 sports card pays:
| Whatnot tier (four-week sales) | Commission on a $100 card |
|---|---|
| Standard ($0 to $14,999) | $8.00 |
| Tier 1 ($15,000 to $34,999) | $7.75 |
| Tier 3 ($50,000 to $99,999) | $7.25 |
| Tier 6 ($500,000+) | $6.50 |
eBay works the other way: its rates for sellers without a Store don't change with volume, though a Store subscription lowers the rate in many categories (not modelled here). Since 1 November 2026, Whatnot's Premier Shop badge no longer comes with an extra commission discount, so your tier alone sets your Whatnot rate. The fee changes page has the dates.
Fees aren't everything
Lower fees only help if the item sells. Things to weigh:
- Time. Whatnot sales mostly happen in live shows you host. An eBay listing keeps working while you sleep. If you have a pile of cheap cards, the time to run a show counts as a cost too.
- Price discovery. Live auctions can push a hot card above what a fixed-price listing gets, or below it on a slow night. On eBay you can wait for your price.
- Below Standard on eBay. Sellers rated Below Standard pay an extra 6% (7% after four or more months in a row), which widens the gap a lot.
- Shipping. On Whatnot the buyer's shipping pays for Whatnot's prepaid label. On eBay you set shipping yourself, so check your label cost covers what you charge.
Many sellers use both: Whatnot shows for volume and fast-moving singles, eBay for slower, higher-value items they want to price carefully.
Run your own numbers
Try your price and category in the Whatnot fee calculator (with every tier) and the eBay fee calculator, or compare all six apps on the homepage. For a closer look at each app on its own, read the Whatnot fee guide and the eBay fee guide.
FAQ
Is Whatnot cheaper than eBay?
For trading cards, coins, collectibles and most clothes, yes. Whatnot charges 8% commission on the item price (4% for coins) plus 2.9% + $0.30 processing. eBay charges 13.25% to 13.6% on the item, shipping and tax, plus $0.40 per order on most sales. A $100 card with $5 shipping leaves $88.65 on Whatnot and $85.69 on eBay. The main exception is athletic shoes at $150 or more, where eBay's 8% rate with no per-order fee comes out cheaper.
How much does Whatnot take compared to eBay on a $40 card?
With $5 buyer-paid shipping and no tax, Whatnot's fees are $4.81 and eBay's are $6.36.
Does Whatnot charge fees on shipping like eBay?
Partly. Whatnot's commission is on the item price only, but its 2.9% + $0.30 processing fee is charged on the whole order, including shipping and tax. eBay's final value fee is charged on the item, shipping and sales tax.
Which is better for expensive cards, Whatnot or eBay?
On fees, Whatnot. In eligible categories it charges no commission on the part of the price above $1,500 (a limited-time promotion). On a $2,000 card with $5 shipping, Whatnot's fees are $178.45 and eBay's are $266.06.
Do Whatnot fees go down if I sell more?
Yes. Whatnot sets your tier from your total sales in a four-week period, and higher tiers pay lower commission in the next period. For sports cards the rate goes from 8% at the Standard tier down to 6.5% at Tier 6. eBay's rates for sellers without a Store don't change with volume.
Does Whatnot's Premier Shop still get a fee discount?
No. Premier Shop's extra 10% commission discount ended on 31 October 2026. From 1 November 2026 your commission rate depends only on your sales tier.
Open the Whatnot fee calculator or the eBay fee calculator, or compare every app on the homepage.
Sources
- Whatnot seller fees (Help Center)
- Reduced commission on high-value orders
- eBay selling fees (Help: fees for sellers without a Store subscription)
- eBay Seller Center: seller fees and worked examples
Fees last checked against these official pages on 2026-11-16. ResaleMath is not affiliated with Whatnot or eBay.